Shy - Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company Share: Download MP3 More song by Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company View all Anything Goes Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company 01:57 Happily Ever After Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company 01:57 Song of Love Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company 01:57 The Swamps of Home Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company 01:57 Witch of the West Side Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company 01:57 The Middle of It All (Finale) Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company 01:57 Do the Right Thing, Greg Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company 01:57 Safety Patrol Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company 01:57 Animal Heart Sutton Foster & Once Upon a Mattress Company 01:57 Similar Artists Brian d'Arcy James Daniel Breaker Gavin Creel Leah Greenhaus Annaleigh Ashford Laura Osnes Original Broadway Cast Colin Donnell Thoroughly Modern Millie Orchestra Marc Kudisch